The shoehorns in his pocket break the crisp lines of his business suit.
Maybe he’s taking them into the courtroom so after he’s sentenced, when he takes off his jacket and steps into the prison jumper, he can slip those shoehorns into his shiny black dress shoes and they’ll hold their shape. In four months, when he gets out of jail, they’ll be just like they were.
Maybe it’s one small thing he can preserve after an eight-month public shaming, a family in “tatters,” a career in ruins.
He’s lost it all. Or so the court has heard and the media has announced again and again about Jack Crone, the 69-year-old bank executive who managed a $200-million portfolio, who kept a cabinet stocked with child pornography in his Vancouver office, plus a home computer loaded with files that together totalled more than 1,200 sex abuse images.
Standing before the judge after pleading guilty, he said he never meant to hurt anyone when he started surfing the net, looking at porn. He said what began as a fringe interest in images of children and minors turned into a habit, a collection that ruined his life.
“I am deeply humiliated,” he said, his shoulders shaking and his voice cracking. “I hope you will give me a chance to make amends.”
Jack Crone’s wife of 11 years left him after police raided his home in the tony British Properties last February. They were looking for a computer, a hard drive registered to Crone that was making hundreds of sex abuse images available for free to people using the file sharing software LimeWire.
When they raided his Vancouver office, they found a locked cabinet, to which Crone held the only key. It contained “documents and photographs,” cartoons about adults and children having sex. A few of the items in collection were classed level five, considered the most offensive and exploitive, showing children subjected to bondage or bestiality.
He told police they were “an arousal mechanism,” and that “he was ashamed of what he had done,” according to sentencing Judge William Rodgers. Crone said he thought it was a “victimless crime.”
Yes he had amassed child porn, but he was just a private collector. He didn’t distribute it – or at least, he didn’t intend to – he said.
What Crone didn’t know was that by using LimeWire, he made the files on his computer accessible to other LimeWire users, which is how police nabbed him.
A billion-dollar industry
Crone told the court he didn’t mean to distribute the files but Constable Rosiane Racine – an investigator with the RCMP Integrated Child Exploitation Unit that nabbed Crone – isn’t convinced.
“From what we understand it would be very difficult for someone not to be fully aware that they were sharing,” she told The Outlook in an interview. “Having said that, he (Crone) claims he didn’t know. We can’t put words into his mouth but I would have a hard time believing that.”
Crone’s arrest came one month before Project Salvo, a multi-agency Canada-wide crackdown on the people who make, sell and collect child pornography. Salvo saw 57 arrests nation-wide, with 11 in B.C. In two of the cases charges will be announced soon, said Racine. For the other nine, the charges are pending.
“The Internet has no borders,” explained Racine, and when child porn collectors trade images – “like baseball cards” as many investigating officers and convicted collectors describe the obsession – the transactions are crossing investigating jurisdictions, and often continents.
The stakes were higher before the Internet, said Racine. Collectors once ordered magazines or photos, swapping images through the mail. Now a video shot in Thailand or Moscow or Kelowna can stream live to anyone who seeks it out, which some investigators say is feeding a body of material growing “more and more shocking,” featuring heightened violence and younger children.
“It (child pornography) did exist, but it wasn’t as accessible to people,” before the web, said Racine. “Now with the Internet it’s become accessible to everyone . . . anybody that has an interest in child sexual abuse material, they can go and get it very easily. For free too.”
What has sprung up with the help of the web are millions of sex abuse photos available at the click of a mouse – experts estimate that circulating at any given time are between 1 and 5-million illicit images. These feed a growing black market estimated to be in the multi-billion-dollar range, according to Canada’s Federal Ombudsman for Victims of Crime, with thousands of new images funneling into circulation every week.
Racine and her unit of nine other officers have their work cut out for them. This year they opened more than 130 files. Searching for collectors like Jack Crone who fuel the demand for contraband abuse images, the RCMP unit screens the glut of material out there, tries to identify where it’s coming from – and, if at all possible, where it was made. But Racine says the chances are not as good that investigators might arrest the producer and rescue the abused child.
“There’s those images that you just basically – your stomach gets all twisted in knots,” said Racine. “There’s a few that just stick with you forever, they’re just so horrifying.”
Checkups with a counsellor are a mandatory part of Racine’s job. “Words cannot even describe the horror that we see these children go through over and over and over again . . . We have to keep going. We owe it to the children to keep going.”
Fall from grace
One reporter will later call Crone’s highly publicized case a “fall from grace.” His lawyer, Richard Peck, tells media, “It’s not going to be easy for someone who’s fallen as far as he has.” The court hears how Crone has lost nearly $3 million in salary, benefits and retirement packages, along with his job as a senior executive at RBC Dominion Securities, where he worked for 38 years.
“It would be an understatement to say that his career has been successful,” says Peck of the $200-million portfolio under Crone’s management before his swift termination in February, and “the consequences of that (firing) are extraordinary.”
UBC law professor Janine Benedet studies prostitution, pornography and sexual assault. In an interview with The Outlook, she cautioned against fixating on Crone’s “associated humiliation . . . you have to be a little bit careful there. Because I’m a bit skeptical of a claim just because you’re wealthy and well connected somehow sending you to jail is worse than somebody else. When you read it that way I think to myself wait, don’t poor people also suffer stigma and shock from their family when they’re convicted of offences like this?”
Crone has been shunned by all but two of his seven children. He is cut off from most of his grandchildren.
“It is fair to say that the personal structure around Mr. Crone has crumbled as a result of this crime,” says Justice Rodgers at Crone’s sentencing, outlining the personal losses suffered by the ex-banker.
Crone sits forward in his chair, listening as the judge challenges his initial assertion that collecting free child porn was “victimless . . . nobody would ever know that I was a viewer, or so I thought.”
“It is difficult to accept that any right thinking person could honestly accept that child pornography is a victimless crime,” explains the judge. He says the mitigating factors in the sentencing are Crone’s apparent remorse, his attempts at seeking regular counselling, his cooperation with police and his letters of support from friends and colleagues. However, he adds, “I cannot overlook the aggravating factors. The images in the videos were both disturbing and disgusting.”
Earlier, the investigating officers showed a sample of those videos to the court in a session closed to the public.
Crown prosecutor Phil Sebellin and the judge each draw the connection between the collectors who fuel the industry – even through gathering free images – and the producers, adults who create a photographic record of child abuse.
In the sentencing Crone gets four months in jail, followed by two years probation. He’ll have to register as a sex offender and provide a DNA sample. He’s forbidden from being around parks, playgrounds or places where children congregate. He can’t work or volunteer where he could be in a position of trust or authority over minors.
He turns and says a stiff, sad goodbye to his siblings and the sheriff takes him away. The scene is short, terse, not nearly as poignant as the exchange that took place just one hour before.
As Crone pulled up to the court house that morning, he faced the TV cameras alone, making the long walk to the courthouse doors.
“Are you remorseful?” asked a cameraman.
“Very,” Crone said softly.
He sat alone in the waiting room. He was reading a newspaper, drinking from a disposable coffee cup. Those shoehorns threatened to fall from his pocket.
As he flipped quickly through the pages, smoothing over his suit, his earlier remarks seemed fitting: “I so much want to regain a measure of self-esteem.”
A pair of investigating officers in the case sat quietly at the other side of the room, hands in their lap, voices low, and Crone quickly acknowledged them with a nod.
Just then two people that he would later introduce as his brother and sister mounted the stairs.
“How you doing?” Crone stood excitedly, embraced the woman, somewhere near her 60s. “So nice of you to come.”
Soon he introduced his family to the officers who caught him.
“She’s a nice lady,” he gestured to the RCMP officer, telling the cops they’ve done a great job.
There was an awkward pause. Both officers nodded. “Thank you.”
kmcmanus@northshoreoutlook.com